Share Pin Email
feature image
Live Free

The Fascinating Science of Why You’re So Hard on Yourself

Most of us battle with an internal voice of self-criticism. A recent psychotherapy review sheds light on how to listen to your inner critic and respond.

443
Author Image
Contributing Writer
SHARE:

This morning, I accidentally knocked over a can of food that splattered all over the floor. Instantly, a voice in my head rang, “Rina, how could you be so stupid? You’ve wasted food and time!”

Sound familiar?

This is the voice commonly referred to as our “inner critic.” In ancient yoga philosophy the inner critic is considered a manifestation of the ego, or ahamkara. As much as ahamkara is involved with deceptively enjoyable vanity and conceit, it can also be the source of painful self-criticism. Peace of mind and self-love, yoga says, come when none of these “snares” of ego entrap us. According to yoga, it is then that we are truly free.

In research terms, the inner critic is defined as a “well-integrated system of critical and negative thoughts and attitudes of the self that interferes with the individual’s organismic experiencing process.” In other words, it is the criticism we hear in our minds that gets in the way of life enjoyment.

History of the Inner Critic

The inner critic, or self-criticism, has become a focus of modern psychotherapy over the last century. In the 1950s American psychotherapist, Carl Rogers, Ph.D., observed a kind of “conditional positive regard”—a more critical view of oneself—in therapy patients. According to Rogers, conditional positive regard toward the self seemed to prevent children from working toward ideals and led to excessive approval seeking in adulthood. In contrast, his therapy work discussed “unconditional positive regard” as a habit of loving oneself through mistakes, big and small. Rogers theorized that with practice of unconditional positive regard, one maintains a healthy self-image and can align with her vision of an ideal self. He referred to this alignment of self-image and actuality as “congruence,” a state of well-being.

In the past decade, scientific research has isolated and explored self-criticism specifically. Studies have revealed strong correlations between negative self-talk and psychopathologies such as depression, social and performance anxiety, aggression, perfectionism and eating disorders, and self-harm. Researchers Paul Gilbert, founder of the Compassionate Mind Foundation in the UK, and Kristin Neff, Ph.D., a self-compassion researcher at the University of Texas, Austin, also found that “self-reassurance” and “self-compassion” are inversely correlated with such psychopathologies. In other words, in each respective study those who practiced more self-reassurance and kind self-talk reported lower levels of depression and anxiety than did those who were naturally not kind or reassuring to themselves. These findings suggest that an inner critic may be more than just an annoyance. It may have an impact our psychological well-being.

Neurophysiology of Self-Criticism

If self-criticism could be psychologically destructive, why might it exist?

As we know, the brain is a highly complex part of the nervous system that helps us navigate, innovate, and survive. In one study lead by Olivia Longe, Ph.D., a research fellow at Aston University’s School of Life and Health Sciences, researchers used fMRI to study activation patterns in the brain as it relates to self-criticism and self-reassurance. Participants were randomly presented 60 pre-screened negative emotion scenarios (e.g., “A third job rejection letter arrived in the post”) and 60 neutral emotion scenarios (e.g., “A free local newspaper arrived in the post”). To half of all scenarios, participants were asked to imagine responding with self-critical thoughts, and to half they were asked to imagine responding with self-reassuring thoughts.


Related: How Embracing Struggle Can Help You Find Success


Among many findings, results of this study revealed a significant association between self-criticism and the lateral prefrontal cortex of the brain including the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC). The DLPFC is said to be involved in error detection and resolution as well as behavioral response inhibition among other functions. These findings suggest that one role of self-criticism is to keep us safe from dangerous repetitive behaviors and possibly life-threatening errors.

When helping protect us from picking up a dangerously sharp object again, self-criticism can be appreciated. When ringing angrily in our heads for sending out party invitations a day late, it’s not hard to see where our inner critic may be assuming excess power.

Much more research is required to learn about the different roots of self-criticism, though thanks to existing studies we know that an inner critic can sound different depending on person or experience. Once we know our inner critic may have a strong presence, how can we respond?

Listening and Responding to Our Inner Critic

Rather than silence or fight off the inner critic, a recent psychotherapy publication led by Nele Stinckens, Ph.D., a researcher at KU Leuven in the Netherlands proposes a “microtheory” to tailor our responses when managing our critical inner voice.

In a 2013 paper published in the Journal of Person-Centered and Experiential Psychotherapies, Stinckens and her team reviewed a broad collection of client-centered and experiential therapist strategies for modifying the inner critic. The findings summarize a flexible approach of strategies “tailored to the nature and intensity of the inner critic…as the best chance of success.” Three strategies are outlined below. While these practices are recommended for a client-therapist setting, some practices may be helpful to the individual.

  1. Identify the inner critic. Stinckens and her team emphasize paying attention to not just the contents of, but to the way, an inner critic speaks. Often, we are not fully aware of the voice but sense the symptoms of depression, anxiety, or anger. By pausing, listening, and actually verbalizing aloud what an inner critic says, one can start to hear the inner critic as separate from the self. For example, you may listen and hear yourself repeat, “You dropped the can of food and now you’ve wasted it and lost precious time!” Repeating accusations out loud in a comfortable space can help you start to hear your inner critic as a separate voice rather than accept it as your own.
  1. Distance yourself from critical thoughts. Once an inner critic has been identified, more verbalization or writing down inner critical thoughts can help create more distance. Analyses revealed that a client visualizing an actual physical inner critic helped to create more space between the voice and the individual. Eventually, clients were often able to evaluate accusations instead of unknowingly accept them as one’s own thoughts and feelings.
  1. If one hears an element of protection in his inner critic’s voice, it’s it may actually have a helpful function. In many therapy cases reviewed in this study, the therapist asked a client to liken the inner critical voice to a personality or an actual role or person. Stinckens’ team found that often the voice had the role of a parent or parental figure, a friend, sibling, or a teacher. Her team further deduces, “By paying attention to the critic’s feelings and concerns and valorizing these, the critic will feel less of a need to constantly manifest itself.” Ideally, this can allow for more trust in the foundation of the critic’s guidance and also encourage behaviors for personal growth. For example, “You’ve dropped the can of food and now you’ve wasted it and lost precious time!” may be reworded as a self-protective, “Take your time so that you can eat well and remain relaxed.”

Stay fluid with the process and meet your inner critic where he or she is. With practice over time, the sound of your critic’s voice may transform: more distant, more compassionate and protective of your well-being.

By

SHARE:

Comments (0)

An Expert Guide to Crow Pose

Download Sonima’s comprehensive guide to this exciting “reach” posture and enjoy the benefits of expert instruction at home!

Get the Guide

Load More

Find us on Instagram

@LIVESONIMA
  • Did you know it’s good to stretch your body after swimming? 
In this article, we offer some yoga postures to open the spine, relax the shoulders, and balance the hips for your post-swim routine. 
See our bio link 🔗 for more photos and a full description of each posture. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
#yogalifestyle #yogaliving #positivenergy #positivelifestyle #positivemindpositivelife
#mindfulliving #livewell #livefree #livefit #sonima #livesonima #healthylivingrevolution #healthierchoices  #balancedlife #createbalance #createhealthyhabits #brainhealth #mindbodyconnection #simplefitness #stayhealthy #yogaforswimmers #stretchtherapy #stretchingexercises #stretchrevolution 
#summertime #exerciseroutine
  • Exercising your body changes your brain, it promotes a more positive outlook, enhances problem solving skills, creates a deeper sense of calm, improves recall, and heightens your cognitive abilities!

The good news is that you not only can enjoy the runner's high, while burning more calories, but running also improves your overall mental clarity. 
Read more... Link in profile! 🏃‍♀️ 🏃 .
.
.
Photo with gratitude from • @spiritualpeople 🙏🏽
.
.
.
.
.
.
#mondaymeditation #mondaymotivation #mondaymood #mondaymiles 
#yogalifestyle #positivenergy #positivelifestyle #positivemindpositivelife 
#mindfulliving #livewell #livefree #livefit #sonima #livesonima #healthylivingrevolution #healthierchoices  #balancedlife #createbalance #createhealthyhabits #brainhealth #mindbodyconnection
#spiritualpeople #spiritualpeoplecommunity #liveyourbestlife #runningmotivation #runninginspiration #runnershigh #runnerslife
  • “Being deeply loved by someone gives you strength, while loving someone deeply gives you courage.”
—Lao Tzu, philosopher and poet

Find 20 more brilliant insights on our website, shared from some of the world's most inspiring thinkers — all on love! 💖 Link in bio. .
.
.
.
.
.
#loveislove #loveislove🌈 #lovequotes #loveyourself #loveisallcolors #selfawareness #meditationchallenge #selflessservice #mindfulnessquotes 
#yogalifestyle #yogaliving #positivenergy #positivelifestyle #positivemindpositivelife
#mindfulliving #livewell #livefree #livefit #sonima #livesonima #healthylivingrevolution #healthierchoices  #balancedlife #createbalance #createhealthyhabits #mindbodyconnection #meditatedaily #meditationinspiration #saturdaymorning
  • .
.
If you have an umbilical hernia, modify your practice by putting less stress on your abdomen. Reduce the intensity and duration of the practice and avoid straining or lifting a lot of weight, which can increase intra-abdominal pressure and worsen the hernia. 
Always make sure to consult your doctor before returning to or beginning a yoga practice with any kind of hernia, or physical health concerns. 🙏🏽
  • The Yoga Sutras are full of ancient wisdom to help cultivate more peace of mind during troubling times. 
Here in sutra 2.33, Patanjali states: “vitarkabādhane pratipakṣabhāvanam” which translates as, “One must cultivate a mental attitude that counteracts the doubts and uncertainties that trouble us.” .

Read the full article as @andrew.hillam explains the valuable significance of this practice and suggests ways to incorporate this age-old advice on how to overcome negative thoughts into your daily life. (Follow the link in our bio) 🙏🏽 .
.
.
.
Photo by @danielletsifoto 🧡 of @sharathjoisr during #sharathjoisusa2019 .
.
.
.
#ashtangayoga #ashtangalove #ashtangavinyasayoga #fitnessmotivation #ashtangafamily #sonima #livesonima #yogahealing #yogaheals #beyondasana #yogaoffthemat #liveyoga #livefit #livehealthy #sharathjois #guruji
#sharathtour2019 #yogalifestyle #yogaliving #positivenergy #positivelifestyle #positivemindpositivelife
#mindfulliving #livewell #thursdaymotivation #thursdaythoughts #yogasutra #yogasutras
  • 3 Ayurvedic Tips to Release Summer Heat:

1. Chill yourself by eating more cooling foods like berries, cucumber, or mint tea.

2. Use coconut oil for massage and practice slow restorative types of exercise.

3. Try cooling pranayama (breathing exercises) and integrate a regular time for calming meditation (see our feathered video). .

For more great ideas and helpful hints on how to rebalance your overheated system during these hot summer months, check out the link in our bio! 🥵 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
#summerheat #tuesdaytransformation #tuesdaymotivation #transformationtuesday #tuesdaymorning #tuesdaymotivation #yogalifestyle #yogaliving #yogadiet #positivenergy #positivelifestyle #positivemindpositivelife 
#mindfulliving #livewell #livefree #livefit #sonima #livesonima #healthylivingrevolution #healthierchoices  #balancedlife #balancediet #createbalance #createhealthyhabits #ayurvedalifestyle #ayurvedaeveryday #ayurveda #ayurvedicfood #ayurvedicmedicine
Receive fresh content delivered to your inbox every week!